As the federal court lawsuit between legal research companies Fastcase, which is now owned by Clio, and Alexi nears it first anniversary, an attempt to resolve the dispute through court-ordered mediation has failed to achieve a settlement.
Fastcase sued the Toronto-based Alexi on Dec. 2, 2025, alleging breach of contract, trademark infringement and trade secret appropriation, all relating to Alexi’s use of data licensed from Fastcase.
Alexi fired back with an answer and counterclaim against Fastcase, vLex, and Clio, which came together as a single company after Fastcase and vLex merged and then were acquired by Clio in a $1 billion deal.
Alexi accused the merged companies of manufacturing breach-of-contract allegations as a pretext to eliminate a competitor in the AI legal research market.
Since then, the parties have engaged in expedited discovery — exchanging thousands of documents and conducting 10 depositions, according to an Alexi filing — and filed cross motions for summary judgment.
On Aug. 24, Alexi filed a motion asking the court to order mediation and set a trial date. It said its financial situation has continued to deteriorate because of the lawsuit and that the company “is stuck in survival mode” pending the outcome of the case.
The court granted the request for mediation and on Nov. 10 participated in a mediation session conducted by Walter D. Kelley Jr., a retired federal judge who served in the Eastern District of Virginia.
On Nov. 12, the parties filed a joint statement notifying the court that they were not able to settle the case at that mediation. They requested that the court schedule a status and scheduling conference to discuss the pending motions to dismiss and the litigation schedule going forward.
As of today, the court has not responded to that request.
Dispute over Data License
As I have written previously based on the parties’ pleadings, the dispute centers on a 2021 license agreement between Fastcase and Alexi — then known as Alexsei — by which Fastcase licensed U.S. caselaw data to Alexi and agreed to provide daily updates of new federal and state judicial opinions.
The agreement said Fastcase was licensing substantial portions of its database “for Alexsei’s legal memos.” Section 1.7 defined the permitted “Purpose” as “internal research purposes,” while also stating that the data could not be used “for commercial purposes” or for any purpose “competitive with Fastcase.”
Section 2.2 separately barred Alexi from selling, licensing, publishing, copying or otherwise distributing any part of the Fastcase data without consent, and Section 5.2 allowed termination for cause only after 30 days’ written notice of a material breach and failure to cure.
That language is the crux of the parties’ dispute. Fastcase says it licensed data for a limited internal memo-support service and that Alexi later pivoted into a customer-facing research platform. Alexi says Fastcase knew from the beginning that Alexi was a commercial AI company using software to automate legal research memoranda, and that Clio, having acquired the agreement, is now trying to read restrictions into it that were never intended.
Robert Ambrogi Blog